What To Do If You Are Sued By A Beneficiary Of The Trust

Dan McKenzie • October 9, 2023

If you have been asked to serve as the successor trustee of a trust after the death of the person who created it, you need. One of the most serious risks is the possibility of being sued by a trust beneficiary. In this blog post, I will explain what you should do if you find yourself in this situation and why you should consult an attorney who specializes in probate and trust administration.


Many people who agree to be trustees worry about the time and effort required to manage the trust assets and distribute them to the beneficiaries according to the trust terms. However, they may not realize that being a trustee also comes with a high level of liability. As a trustee, you have a fiduciary duty to act in the beneficiaries' best interests and follow the trust agreement's instructions. If you fail to do so, even unintentionally or in good faith, you may be held personally liable for any losses or damages caused by your actions or inactions.


Moreover, even if you are doing everything right as a trustee, you may still face a lawsuit from a disgruntled beneficiary who is unhappy with your decisions or the instructions the trust maker left behind. Unfortunately, anyone can sue anyone in our legal system, regardless of how strong their case is. Being a trustee can sometimes mean making tough choices that may upset some beneficiaries, even if those choices are consistent with the trust agreement and the law. For example, you may have to sell some assets a beneficiary wanted, pay taxes or expenses that reduce what the beneficiaries ultimately receive, or deny beneficiary requests.


So, what should you do if you receive a threat or a notice of a lawsuit from a beneficiary? The first thing you should do is review the trust agreement carefully. It may contain provisions that can help you deal with the dispute. For instance, it may require that any conflicts be resolved through mediation or arbitration instead of litigation. This can save you time, money, and stress. It may also allow you to use the trust funds to pay your legal fees and expenses. This can protect you from having to pay out of your pocket. It may also include an indemnification clause that shields you from personal liability for any claims arising from your role as trustee.


However, before you take any action or make any statement, you should seek legal advice from an attorney experienced in probate and trust administration. This is because you may have personal liability for any mistakes or admissions you make in responding to the lawsuit. You should not ignore or dismiss any lawsuit threat, but you should also not panic or react impulsively. You should act diligently and professionally and follow the guidance of your attorney.


Being a trustee can be a rewarding but challenging role. You may have to deal with complex legal and financial issues and emotional and interpersonal conflicts. If a beneficiary sues you, you should not take it personally, but you should take it seriously. You should review the trust agreement, consult an attorney, and respond appropriately. By doing so, you can protect yourself and fulfill your fiduciary duty.

What next?

If you are serving as the executor of an estate, whether through probate or a trust administration, you can:


  1. Call 720-821-7604 to schedule an "Attorney Evaluation Session," to determine whether our firm would be a good fit for your needs. Or fill out our contact form to have us call you.
  2. Visit our estate administration page to learn how proactively thinking through your estate plan can protect you and your family, minimize hassle, lower the chance of family discord, and minimize or eliminate taxes.
  3. Learn more by reading our blog or watching our videos.


By Dan McKenzie June 18, 2026
Discover how a properly structured trust can keep your financial affairs out of public court records and protect your family's privacy in Colorado.
By Dan McKenzie June 17, 2026
Discover why choosing the right successor trustee is the most critical part of your estate plan. Learn how a backup manager keeps your Denver family out of court.
By Dan McKenzie June 16, 2026
Think a living trust fully protects your family from probate? Discover when probate is unavoidable in Colorado and how to keep your assets secure.
By Dan McKenzie June 15, 2026
Thinking about using an online template for your will? Discover the common DIY estate planning mistakes that could leave your Denver family unprotected.
By Dan McKenzie June 15, 2026
Are online wills a scam? Learn why an online DIY will might be legal, but could still fail your family when they need it most.
Light blue two-story house behind a hedge beside a canal under a cloudy sky
By Dan McKenzie June 12, 2026
Can probate delay the sale of a house in Colorado? Learn how probate affects real estate sales, common causes of delays, and how The McKenzie Law Firm, LLC helps Centennial families navigate probate.
By Dan McKenzie June 10, 2026
Discover what happens to bank accounts after death. Learn the key differences between joint and individual accounts, and how to avoid Colorado probate court.
By Dan McKenzie June 8, 2026
Wondering why Matthew Perry’s estate ended up in probate court? Discover how to align your assets and avoid common mistakes with a comprehensive estate plan.
Draining your home equity to hide assets from a lawsuit will backfire. Learn why courts reject last-
By Dan McKenzie June 7, 2026
Draining your home equity to hide assets from a lawsuit will backfire. Learn why courts reject last-minute loans and how to protect your wealth legally.
By Dan McKenzie June 6, 2026
Inheriting a family home can spark bitter sibling rivalries. Learn why a property appraisal protects your family from capital gains tax and future conflicts.