Supreme Court Rules Medicaid Can Recoup Against Settlement Funds for Future Medical Payments
July 27, 2022
The Supreme
Court of the United States issued a ruling last week that dictates that a state’s Medicaid agency can recoup funds for benefits paid against an injured party’s settlement award for future medical expenses.
In this case , a Florida student was tragically injured and left in a vegetative state when she was hit by a truck after she stepped off her school bus. Her personal injury suit settled with an $800,000 award, of which roughly $35,000 was designated for past medical expenses. Instead of taking the amount designated for past medical expenses, the state Medicaid agency tried to attach $300,000 of the settlement proceeds.
The Medicaid Act requires states to seek reimbursement from third parties who are liable for a recipient’s medical care. As a result, Florida enacted the Medicaid Third-Party Liability Act, which automatically attaches a lien to settlement proceeds that an injured applicant receives from a case “that necessitated that Medicaid provide medical assistance.” (See Fla. Stat. §§409.910(6)(c), (6)(c)(1), 409.901(7)(a).) Generously, the state’s statute limits recovery to 37.5% of the injured party’s total recovery amount.
The plaintiffs argued that federal statute prohibited a state from attaching settlement funds for future medical expenses. While the Medicaid Act prohibits a Medicaid agency from seeking reimbursement from a recipient’s property, the SCOTUS interpreted 42 U. S. C. §1396k(a)(1)(A) to allow a state Medicaid agency to seek reimbursement for both past and future medical care expenses from a personal injury settlement
In this case , a Florida student was tragically injured and left in a vegetative state when she was hit by a truck after she stepped off her school bus. Her personal injury suit settled with an $800,000 award, of which roughly $35,000 was designated for past medical expenses. Instead of taking the amount designated for past medical expenses, the state Medicaid agency tried to attach $300,000 of the settlement proceeds.
The Medicaid Act requires states to seek reimbursement from third parties who are liable for a recipient’s medical care. As a result, Florida enacted the Medicaid Third-Party Liability Act, which automatically attaches a lien to settlement proceeds that an injured applicant receives from a case “that necessitated that Medicaid provide medical assistance.” (See Fla. Stat. §§409.910(6)(c), (6)(c)(1), 409.901(7)(a).) Generously, the state’s statute limits recovery to 37.5% of the injured party’s total recovery amount.
The plaintiffs argued that federal statute prohibited a state from attaching settlement funds for future medical expenses. While the Medicaid Act prohibits a Medicaid agency from seeking reimbursement from a recipient’s property, the SCOTUS interpreted 42 U. S. C. §1396k(a)(1)(A) to allow a state Medicaid agency to seek reimbursement for both past and future medical care expenses from a personal injury settlement
What next?
If you are plan around a potential need for Medicaid assistance, you can:
- Give us a call at 720-821-7604 to schedule a "Discovery Session" at which we can determine whether our firm would be a good fit for your needs. Or fill out our contact form to have us call you.
- Visit our estate planning page to learn more about how proactively thinking through your estate plan can protect you and your family, minimize hassle, lower the chance of family discord, and minimize or eliminate taxes.
- Learn more by reading our blog or watching our videos .
Think estate planning is only for parents? Think again. Learn why childless adults in Colorado need a solid estate plan — and what’s at stake if you don’t have one.
Are your adult kids living at home? Learn why residency doesn't equal ownership and how to protect your Denver home with a solid estate plan.
Learn why verbal promises aren't enough in Colorado probate court and how a formal estate plan from The McKenzie Law Firm can protect your Denver family.
Lost on how to access a loved one's bank account or sell their house? Learn how the probate process works in Denver and how to get the legal authority you need.
Dividing your estate equally among your children might seem fair, but it can lead to family conflict. Learn why equal isn't always fair for family caregivers in Denver.
Inheriting a house is much harder than inheriting cash or stocks. Learn why real estate causes family conflict and how to protect your Denver home with a plan.
Discover what happens to your online accounts when you die and how to protect your digital assets. Expert advice for Denver families from The McKenzie Law Firm.
Choosing a child as your executor can lead to family fighting. Learn why Denver estate planning experts suggest neutral alternatives to protect your legacy.
Wondering if you can pay your parents' bills from their bank account after they pass away? Learn why accounts get frozen and how to protect your family in Denver.
Did you know creditors often get paid before your family in probate? Learn how the Colorado probate process works and how to protect your Denver family's inheritance.